Clemente

The arc of his life unfolds like a parable.

He was a justly proud Latin player, at a time - two generations ago - when such players were few. His first name was Roberto, yet the Pittsburgh press, all-too-quick to Anglicize, dubbed him "Bobby." The would-be diminutive was not just incongruous; it was insulting.

His was a magnificent all-around game, based on flawless fielding, a rifle arm in right field, and a splendid combination of speed and power at the plate and on the basepaths. He led the Pirates to the World Series title in 1971 and, at the very end of the 1972 season, doubled in his final at bat for his 3,000th hit.

Only a few months later, on December 23, 1972, a massive earthquake hit Nicaragua, killing over 10,000 people and destroying the capital, Managua. To make this even worse, international aid could not get through to people in need because the dictatorship run by Anastasio Samosa was, as several authors have documented, a "kleptocracy."

Clemente took it upon himself to cut through confusion and government theft. He organized a relief mission, based in Puerto Rico, and on New Year's Eve, 1972, took off with four others in a small DC-7 plane loaded with food and supplies. Sadly, the plane crashed into the Caribbean soon after leaving the airport in San Juan.

Today, in the wake of the Hatian and Chilean earthquakes, the passion that drove his attempt to aid the earthquake victims in Nicaragua is a more timely example than ever. And the annual award given by Major Leage Baseball for humanitarian service is still rightly called the Roberto Clemente Award.

Trespass and the Homeless

Trespass is a venerable legal term, one of the building blocks of the common law. The definitions in Black’s Law Dictionary of the various types go on and on for pages, hinting at archaic hair-splitting now largely lost to time. Trespass on the case, trespass to chattels, and so on — with criminal trespass only one, comparatively compact, meaning among many.

Today, in America, it is the criminal meaning that prevails. Going on someone else’s property without permission is against the law and can be prosecuted as a criminal offense. In our mind’s eye, many of us still see the context for such an offense as, say, a hunter ignoring a “no trespassing” sign in order to hunt for deer or other game on private land.

Tonight’s PBS report from Miami on homeless people taking up residence in foreclosed homes showed the old concept of trespass bumping up against our complex contemporary reality. The NOW program followed Max Rameau, a community activist whose organization, Take Back the Land, seeks to match responsible homeless families (not by any means an oxymoron) with empty homes that are still livable.

This used to be called “squatting,” and it is still against the law. Rambeau’s response is that it is immoral to leave people on the street when society has failed to build enough affordable housing and the Great Recession relentlessly adds to the ranks of the homeless. Nationally, depending on how homelessness is measured, those numbers are expected to rise from roughly 3 million to roughly 4 million people who will be homeless at one time or another this year. How many of us would have thought, as recently as two years ago, that tent cities would spring up in America?

There is also a very particular back story in South Florida. In 2006, the Miami Herald broke the story about rampant fraud in the Miami-Dade public housing agency. The paper won a Pulitzer Prize for revealing that Oscar Rivero, a developer who had taken over $700,000 in public money to build 54 affordable housing units, had actually spent the money on a house for himself, complete with appliances, pool, and of course thorough termite inspection. The Herald’s investigation revealed numerous other instances of fraud in the agency — so many, indeed, that the federal Housing and Urban Development agency took control of it.

For me, this background complicates the moral calculus of whether the civil disobedience Rambeau’s group is engaging in is justified. Does it promote a culture of lawlessness that will further undermine neighborhoods, contributing to more crime and homelessness? In other words, is Rambeau an urban Rambo, taking the law into his own ends in a reckless manner, like Sylvester Stallone’s movie character?

Perhaps it would help to get down to cases. The NOW program highlighted a story about a single mother trying to get a Ph. D. while working a cleaning job. She moved into a foreclosed house with her children, only to return one day to find their belongings strewn about the property. After Rambeau organized a media event to confront the property management company, the woman and her family ended up staying for a few more months in the house. What difficult judgment calls situations like this must be for law enforcement and prosecutors, having to decide whether to use their discretion to seek trespassing charges against people looking for nothing more than a roof over their heads.